Ontario Keeping Its Promise to Put Drivers First
T-Bone Accidents – Dangerous and Often Hard To Determine Who Is At Fault
Five ways to navigate an insurance claim
Expert Access Solves Cashflow Issue for Law Firms and Experts
What happens in an LTD lawsuit?
Injured provincial workers group bringing human rights concerns to UN
Ontario Injured Workers Bring Concerns to the United Nations
Hope for Spinal Cord Injury Treatment
[7] The Plaintiff’s claim arises from infections suffered by a group of some 21 patients who were administered epidural steroid injections by Dr. James. The class members were all infected patients at the Defendant, Rothbart Centre For Pain Care Ltd. (“Rothbart Centre”), where Dr. James practiced.
[8] The Defendants are Dr. James, the Rothbart Centre (which is now insolvent), the Rothbart Centre’s administrator, Dr. Peter Rothbart, and 16 nurses who worked at the Rothbart Centre during the relevant time. The central issues in this motion are whether there are sufficient common issues and whether a class proceeding is the preferable procedure for the purposes of ss. 5(1)(c) and (d) of the Class Proceedings Act, 1992, SO 1992, c 6 (“CPA”).
[9] More specifically, this case raises the question of whether statistical evidence with respect to rates of infection and evidence of Dr. James’ infection prevention and control (“IPAC”) practices can amount to proof of causation and standard of care for the purposes of tort liability, or whether the cause of each claimant’s injury must be determined individually. There is conflicting evidence as to whether or not Dr. James IPAC practices were uniformly implemented with respect to all of his patients. There is also some contentious evidence about likely sources of the infections.
For those unfamiliar with this case:
Levac v. James, 2017 ONCA 842 (CanLII), <http://canlii.ca/t/hmvrb
Levac v. James, 2017 ONCA 842 (CanLII), <http://canlii.ca/t/hmvrb
Did you attend the Rothbart Pain Clinic for treatment? If so, you may want to read the Toronto Star articles below.
https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2015/12/15/toronto-doctor-at-centre-of-outbreak-loses-licence-for-10-months.html
Discipline hearing told MD tried to thwart investigation Anesthesiologist at centre of outbreak has pleaded no contest to incompetence and dishonourable conduct. Disciplinary body is told infected patients lost mobility, independence and control of their bladders. http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2015/11/16/discipline-hearing-told-md-tried-to-thwart-investigation.html
Public not told of infection outbreak at private Toronto pain clinic Sat Sep 20 2014
Infection outbreak at pain clinic sparks calls for greater transparency Tue Sep 23 2014
Pain clinic doctor faces disciplinary hearing after outbreak Thu Sep 25 2014
Rothbart Centre outbreak might have started earlier: lawyer Sun Oct 05 2014
Ontario health minister orders data on clinics made public Sun Oct 05 2014